Do I Need an Appraisal to Sell a Parent's Home Under a Power of Attorney?

It is not always legally required, but it is usually a sensible step. In Ontario, an attorney under a continuing power of attorney for property is governed by the Substitute Decisions Act, 1992. That law requires you to act honestly, with integrity and in good faith for the benefit of the person you are acting for, and to keep accounts of what you do with their property. When the asset is a parent’s home, an independent appraisal is a clear, written record that the price you accepted was reasonable on the date you sold.
It also protects you. Brothers, sisters and other family members may ask questions later, and a court can order an attorney to pass their accounts. A report prepared before the sale answers the most obvious question, which is what the home was worth.
When This Question Comes Up
The situations we see most often in London and across Southwestern Ontario include:
-
A parent moving into long-term care: the home needs to be sold to pay for care or because no one will be living in it.
-
A parent moving into retirement living: the family home is no longer needed and the attorney is handling the sale.
-
A vacant home that needs a decision: the parent has not lived there for some time and the attorney has to decide whether to keep, rent or sell it.
-
A family member who wants to buy the home: a child or other relative offers to purchase it, sometimes the attorney themselves.
-
A court-appointed guardian of property: the same duties apply when a guardian, rather than an attorney named by the parent, manages the property.
Whether you have authority to sell, and whether your parent is incapable of managing property, are legal questions for your lawyer. Our role is to provide an independent opinion of market value.
Why the Attorney’s Duties Matter
An attorney for property is a fiduciary. You are not selling your own house, and the decisions you make are judged by whether they served the person you act for. In general terms, the Substitute Decisions Act and its regulation on accounts and records expect an attorney to:
-
Act for the person’s benefit: the sale should make sense for your parent, not for the attorney or other family members.
-
Keep accounts: records of what was sold, when and for how much, along with the documents that support those transactions.
-
Be ready to explain decisions: a court can order an attorney to pass accounts, and family members can ask for that.
The Act also says an attorney or guardian should not dispose of property they know is the subject of a specific gift in the person’s will, unless the sale is necessary to meet their duties. If your parent’s will leaves the home to someone, speak with your lawyer before you list it.
An appraisal does not replace legal advice and does not decide whether a sale is appropriate. What it does is give you an independent, supported value to rely on when you make the decision and record it.
When a Family Member Wants to Buy
This is where an appraisal matters most. If you, your spouse or a relative wants to buy the home, the sale is not at arm’s length and the attorney is on both sides of the interest. Your lawyer may advise extra steps in this situation, such as the consent of other family members or court approval, depending on the facts and the wording of the power of attorney.
Whatever path your lawyer recommends, the first question will be whether the price reflects market value. A report from an independent appraiser, with comparable sales and the property’s condition documented, is much easier to defend than a price agreed around the kitchen table. For the tax side of transfers within a family, see our post on selling or gifting a home to a family member.
Why an MPAC Assessment or an Online Estimate Is Not Enough
An MPAC assessment is prepared for property tax and is valued as of a fixed base date. It is not an opinion of market value on the date you sell. Our post on market value vs. assessed value explains the difference.
Automated online estimates do not inspect the home. Many parents’ homes have been lived in for decades, and a long period of ownership can mean original kitchens and baths, older mechanical systems or deferred maintenance that a computer model cannot see. It can also mean a solid, well-kept house in an established neighbourhood. An appraiser inspects the property and reflects its actual condition.
What the Appraiser Needs From You
A clear brief helps the report fit its purpose. Helpful items include:
-
The purpose: for example, supporting a sale by an attorney for property, or a proposed sale to a family member.
-
The effective date: usually a current date before the home is listed or an offer is accepted. Your lawyer may ask for a different date.
-
Access to the home: a time to inspect, keeping in mind the home may be vacant or partly packed up.
-
What you know about the property: past renovations, roof and furnace dates, known issues, and any recent repairs.
-
Your lawyer’s contact details: so the report is addressed to the right people and suits what they need.
If the home has already been sold, an appraisal can be prepared as of a past date. The appraiser researches sales and market conditions as they were at that time.
Local Considerations in London and Area
A parent’s home might be a bungalow in an older London neighbourhood, a two-storey house in St. Thomas or Woodstock, or a country property outside Strathroy or St. Marys. Each market has its own comparable sales, and the value has to reflect the specific area and the home’s condition on the effective date. See our London, St. Thomas, Woodstock, Strathroy and St. Marys pages for the communities we cover.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Ontario law require an appraisal before an attorney sells a home?
The Substitute Decisions Act does not set out a general rule that every sale needs an appraisal. It does require an attorney to act for the person’s benefit and to keep accounts. An appraisal is a common way to show the price was reasonable. Your lawyer can tell you what your situation calls for.
Can I buy my parent’s home if I am their attorney?
It may be possible, but it raises a conflict of interest. Speak with your lawyer before making an offer. Whatever steps they recommend, an independent appraisal is a starting point for showing the price was fair.
Is the appraisal the same as a listing price?
No. An appraisal is an independent opinion of market value as of a specific date. It is not a listing recommendation, and the appraiser has no interest in the sale.
Can the appraisal also be used later for the estate?
A report is prepared for a stated purpose and effective date. If your parent later passes away, the estate will usually need a value as of the date of death, which is a separate assignment. Our estate appraisal page explains that work.
Does Riverbend give legal advice?
No. We provide an independent, CUSPAP-compliant opinion of market value. Your lawyer advises on your authority and duties as attorney.
Getting a Value Before You Sell
If you are managing a parent’s home under a power of attorney, an independent appraisal gives you and your family a supported figure to rely on. Learn more about our residential appraisals, see how we work with lawyers and accountants, or request an appraisal with the address and the purpose of the report.


